Creating a Course That Thrives Without You: Building an Exceptional Learning Culture

The student-to-teacher pipeline

Last week, I was absolutely floored when I read the testimonials from the most recent course I led for the Lefkoe Institute.

What made these testimonials particularly interesting? I barely participated in running this cohort.

My instructors handled nearly everything, and the results weren't just good—they were exceptional. Students raved about the experience, the culture, and the transformation they underwent.

Here's what fascinates me: Even with my limited involvement, the feedback was extraordinary.

This is especially remarkable because the course teaches a sophisticated style of coaching with technical elements that many students have historically struggled with. In the past, a significant number of students failed to master these techniques well. Yet this time, the success rate was extraordinary.

Let's get into why this happened and what you can learn from it for your own courses.

The "Former Student to Teacher" Pipeline

What made our course so successful despite my limited involvement?

The instructors running it were all former students themselves. They'd experienced the transformation firsthand before stepping into teaching roles. Some have been instructors for one year, others for two, three, or even four years.

This creates a unique dynamic where our teachers aren't just delivering content—they're living testimonials of the process they're guiding others through.

What Students Noticed (That Most Courses Get Wrong)

The testimonials revealed specific elements that made the experience stand out. Here's what students highlighted:

1. Detailed, specific feedback
Students mentioned receiving thoughtful, detailed feedback each day—not just "good job" comments. This level of personalized attention made them feel valued and helped them improve more rapidly.

2. A culture of openness
Whenever a student made a suggestion, instructors genuinely listened and tried to incorporate it. This wasn't lip service—students could see their input shaping the course in real-time.

3. Vulnerability and compassion
Since our course involves personal development, students revealed very personal challenges. What struck many was how compassionate everyone was—both instructors and fellow students. This didn't happen by accident; our instructors modeled this behavior consistently.

4. Humble leadership
One student specifically mentioned how instructors would "admit" when they learned something new from a student and would credit that student by name. They didn't pretend to know everything already—a refreshing change from the typical expert-knows-all dynamic.

5. Rapid implementation of feedback
When something didn't work, we fixed it almost immediately. Students were amazed at how quickly we'd implement improvements based on their suggestions—something many hadn't experienced in other courses.

6. Freedom with materials
We intentionally made our materials easy to duplicate, print, and modify. Students noted that other courses often make materials difficult to use outside the platform and might even scold those who ask about exporting content.

No Student Left Behind

One philosophy we've adopted is "no student left behind."

When students didn't show up or stopped participating, we proactively reached out—not in an accusatory way, but from genuine care. In one case, after multiple unanswered emails, we called a student directly and discovered there was a typo in his email address. He wasn't receiving any of our communications!

I've been in courses where problems like this go undetected until the very end. I remember one course where a student mentioned on the final day that she had been unable to access the materials throughout the entire program and never received responses to her help requests. She felt like "just a number."

In contrast, our approach ensures that even if a student chooses not to participate, they know we noticed and cared enough to reach out.

Be Intentional About Your Course Culture

Many courses unintentionally create a culture of "I'm the expert, and you're not."

We've deliberately fostered a different environment where instructors position themselves as fellow students—just ones who've been studying longer. This "we're all still learning" mindset permeates everything we do.

Our instructors don't rely on their certification or experience to claim authority. Instead, they share what they've observed while remaining open to different perspectives and experiences. There's never a "I know because I've been certified" attitude.

Even as part of our certification process, instructors must show evidence of continued learning. The message is clear: none of us have reached the end of the path.

How to Select and Train Exceptional Instructors

Our instructor selection process happened organically. As we improved our courses and marketing around 2019-2020, the courses filled with enthusiastic students. Some were so impressed that they approached us saying, "I really want to be part of what you're doing. Can I help teach?"

This self-selection process works because our courses are designed for students to give each other feedback—not just receive it from teachers. This allows us to observe how potential instructors communicate, their attitudes toward others, and their approach to teaching before they ever take on an official role.

This is critical: If your course design enables students to become teachers within the course structure, you create a natural pipeline for identifying future instructors. But if students are always just recipients of knowledge, you'll never discover who among them might make exceptional teachers.

The Bigger Lesson

The most powerful insight from this experience is that a well-designed course with the right culture and properly trained instructors can continue to deliver exceptional results even when the course author isn't directly involved in day-to-day operations.

By focusing on building systems, training past students as instructors, and intentionally creating a culture of continuous improvement and compassion, you can develop a program that scales without sacrificing quality—and perhaps even improves as it grows beyond your direct control.

How to Apply This to Your Course

1. Design your course to include peer teaching opportunities
   Create structures where students can guide each other, not just consume your content.

2. Document your culture explicitly
   Don't assume the values and behaviors you want will naturally emerge—make them explicit.

3. Identify potential instructors from your student body
   Look for those who embody your values and demonstrate a love for teaching.

4. Create systems to ensure no student falls through the cracks
   Develop protocols for reaching out to disengaged students and troubleshooting access issues.

5. Model the humility and continuous learning you want to see
   If you want instructors who admit when they learn from students, you need to do the same.

Remember, the goal isn't to remove yourself entirely—it's to create something so robust that it carries your values forward even when you're not directly involved.

---

Still here? I love that. Leave a comment or reply to this email and tell me what you think of these ideas. I read every message and they make my day.

Two ways I can help you

The Atomic Course Blueprint - Want to create a course without the usual overwhelm? Try creating a tiny course. Find out more here.

iPARA: How to organize your digital life for action - Is digital disorganization keeping you from reaching your goals? What if just four folders could let you not just stay organized but actually get things done. See for yourself here.